Conversation with a Nonbeliever

Why don’t you believe in God anymore? Why aren’t you a Christian?

Upon examining my religious beliefs, I found that they were not as well founded as I initially thought they were. Put simply, the reasons given in support of theism are insufficient to warrant its acceptance. Religious apologists have tried to remedy this by presenting various arguments for the existence of God. Yet the most common arguments they use would only lend support to a vague form of deism at best. Most apologists are not deists. They are Christians, Muslims, and Jews — people who subscribe to elaborate theologies that encompass claims about the nature, identity, and will of God, as well as claims about sin, salvation, miracles, and even the origins and ultimate fate of the universe.

In arguing the case for a particular religion, such as Christianity, providing a compelling reason for belief in God is therefore only the first step. Apologists still have a long road ahead if they are to establish the truth of their various other claims about the supernatural.

There are many questions that science cannot answer, but which religion can. Religion makes sense of things that science fails to.

If science cannot make sense of some problem or explain some phenomenon, it doesn’t necessarily follow that religion can. That something is beyond our current understanding doesn’t imply that some supernatural force must be at play; it just means that we are ignorant. Appealing to the supernatural as an answer doesn’t solve anything; it doesn’t further our understanding of the universe in any meaningful way. And if that’s the case, then we can carry on inquiring without it.

The truth of my theology is confirmed by my sensus divinitatis, the inner witness of the Holy Spirit in my heart.

What of those whose sensus divinitatis leads them to theological commitments that differ to your own? Why lend so much epistemic weight to your personal sensus divinitatis? What makes you think that your own sensus divinitatis is more reliable than that of someone of a different religion who feels just as strongly about his theological commitments as you do about yours?

Without belief in God, life is meaningless. There is no wonder or joy, only despair.

Some people believe that everything must be imbued with theological significance or else it has no significance at all; it’s meaningless. I don’t subscribe to this nihilistic worldview. When I gaze upward into stelliferous skies, I don’t feel as though life is devoid of meaning. The cosmos is awe-inspiring on its own; one need not view it through a theological lens to be enthused with wonder.

Why do you care? Why can’t you just let people believe whatever it is they want to believe?

Because ideas matter; ideas guide actions, which have real practical consequences. Too often, we find that political decisions are made on a religiously motivated basis. Such decisions affect us all, which is why we have an interest in examining the rationale behind them.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s